Fair Chance Hiring Laws: What US Employers Must Do
Fair chance hiring laws explained for US employers: federal rules, state and city ban-the-box laws, the step-by-step process, and how to stay compliant.
standard employment reports
Invite a candidate, they verify their ID on their phone, and you get a national criminal report. Flat price, nothing monthly.
Get started See pricingIn this report
Fair Chance Hiring Laws: What US Employers Must Do

Fair chance hiring laws limit when and how an employer may consider a criminal record. Most require you to hold off on conviction questions and background checks until later in the process, and to weigh an applicant’s record against the job before you reject them. The rules differ by federal agency, state and city, so the safest approach is one repeatable process that meets the strictest rule you face. We built PreHireBadge’s national criminal report, with adverse action handling included in every account, so that process is not something you assemble by hand.
TL;DR
- Fair chance (or “ban the box”) laws move criminal-history questions and background checks to later in hiring, usually after an interview or a conditional offer.
- Fifteen states extend these laws to private employers, and more than 150 cities and counties have their own rules, so check where each employee will work.
- Before rejecting someone over a record, assess the offense, the time passed and the job, then send a written preliminary notice and allow a response.
- Build one process that follows the strictest rule you face, rather than a separate one per city.
- Automated notices, timelines and audit records turn the legal steps into routine work.
Table of Contents
- What fair chance hiring means
- The layers of fair chance law in the US
- When you may ask about a record or run a check
- How to assess a record: the three factors
- The fair chance hiring process, step by step
- Exceptions, complaints and penalties
- Where employers get tripped up
- Our perspective
- Run fair chance screening with PreHireBadge
- FAQ
- Sources
What fair chance hiring means
Fair chance hiring means evaluating candidates on qualifications, skills and readiness for the role rather than automatically excluding them because of past history. A record becomes one factor, considered at the right time and in the right way, instead of a filter that removes people before anyone reads their application.
The National Employment Law Project describes the usual building blocks of a fair chance policy: removing conviction-history questions from applications, delaying background checks, and requiring individualized consideration of the applicant’s record and the job sought. Those three pieces show up, in different combinations, in nearly every law described below.
A fair chance hiring policy is your written version of those pieces. It says when in your process a record may come up, who reviews it, what factors they apply, and what notices go out if the decision is negative.
Why employers adopt the policy even where the law does not require it
Policy guidance for private employers points to labor-pool loyalty and stability, economic benefits and lower recidivism as reasons to hire people with records, and notes that reentry service providers can connect employers with vetted, trained workers. A consistent policy also gives every hiring manager the same rules, which is the best protection against uneven decisions.
The layers of fair chance law in the US
There is no single national fair chance law for private employers. You deal with four layers at once.
| Layer | Who it covers | What it typically does |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Fair Chance Act | Federal agencies and contractors acting for them | Bars criminal-history requests before a conditional offer, with listed exceptions |
| State laws | Public employers in many states, private employers in some | Remove the question from applications, delay checks, set notice steps |
| City and county ordinances | Employers with workers in that locality | Often add stricter timing, written assessments and response windows |
| Federal anti-discrimination and credit-reporting law | Nearly all employers | Title VII guidance on records, FCRA notice and consent rules |
The federal Fair Chance Act
The Fair Chance to Compete for Jobs Act was signed into law on December 20, 2019 as part of the National Defense Authorization Act for fiscal year 2020. It limits when agencies may request criminal-history information and requires a complaint process for applicants. With some exceptions, the implementing regulations prohibit federal agencies and contractors acting on their behalf from requesting an applicant’s criminal-history information before a conditional offer. If you hire for federal work, this rule applies to you even if your state has none.
State laws
As of the National Employment Law Project’s October 2021 guide, 37 states and more than 150 cities and counties had adopted ban-the-box policies. Fifteen states extended them to private employment: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington. Lists like this change as legislatures act, so confirm the current status for any state where you hire.
A few examples show how much the details vary:
- California. The Civil Rights Department says its Fair Chance Act generally prohibits employers with five or more employees from asking about conviction history before a job offer.
- Washington. The state’s Fair Chance Act (RCW 49.94) protects applicants and employees with criminal records so they can compete fairly for jobs. The Attorney General’s office publishes updates, so review its page for current amendments.
- Illinois, Colorado and Arizona each have their own statutes with different employer thresholds and timing.
Our own Ban the Box guide goes deeper on the state and local picture for employers.
City and county ordinances
Local rules are often the most detailed. Under the Los Angeles County ordinance, covered employers must make a written individualized assessment, give a preliminary notice and the report, allow a response, then conduct a second assessment before a final adverse decision. San Francisco’s ordinance adds that if an applicant provides timely evidence of inaccuracy or rehabilitation, the employer must delay adverse action for a reasonable time and reconsider.
Why compliance gets complicated
Legal scholars note that despite the spread of these laws, compliance is complex because employee thresholds, covered employer types and the definition of job-related exclusions differ across jurisdictions. That is the practical reason to run one strict process everywhere instead of tracking dozens of variations by hand.
When you may ask about a record or run a check
The timing rule is the core of fair chance law. The common pattern is:
- Application stage. No conviction-history question on the form or in the posting.
- Interview stage. In many jurisdictions you still may not ask, or run a check, until after the first interview.
- Conditional offer. In most laws, this is the earliest point to ask or run a check. The offer is conditional on a satisfactory result.
- After the check. If something relevant appears, you start the individualized assessment, not an automatic rejection.
The federal rule follows the same shape: no request for criminal-history information before a conditional offer, subject to the exceptions in the statute and regulations. Those exceptions generally cover positions where other law requires a check or the Fair Chance Act itself lists an exclusion. If your role may qualify, confirm it with an employment attorney before relying on it.
Our Background Check Requirements by Role tool helps you decide what screening scope fits a position before you reach the conditional offer stage.
How to assess a record: the three factors
The EEOC’s enforcement guidance, issued in 2012, recommends that employers use the Green factors to avoid Title VII liability: the nature and gravity of the offense, the time that has passed since the offense or sentence, and the nature of the job.
In practice, write the answer to each factor down:
- Nature and gravity. What was the offense, and what did it involve? A decades-old, low-level offense differs from a recent one.
- Time passed. When did the offense or sentence end? Note it in the file.
- Nature of the job. Does the offense relate to the duties, the setting or the people the worker would be around? A driving record matters for a delivery role in a way it may not for a back-office role.
The written assessment is also your evidence if a decision is ever challenged. Our summary of EEOC background check guidance shows how employers apply these factors today.
The same discipline matters for how far back you look. See how far back a background check goes before you set a lookback period in your policy.
Hospitality and seasonal employers face the same questions at volume. For one industry’s view, read about applicant screening at theme parks.
The fair chance hiring process, step by step
This sequence satisfies the strictest local rules and the federal credit-reporting requirements. Where a city or state sets longer windows, use the longer window.
1. Remove record questions from the application
Delete the checkbox and any wording that asks about convictions. Audit job postings and third-party job boards too, since a leftover question creates exposure. The legal checks belong later.
2. Interview and make a conditional offer
Make the offer on the basis of skills and fit, stating that it depends on a satisfactory background check. If you screen for job knowledge, a short job-knowledge test is a record-neutral way to compare candidates at this stage. We explain it in our guide to using a job-knowledge quiz.
3. Get disclosure and authorization
Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, you need a clear written disclosure and the candidate’s authorization before a report is ordered. Our FCRA authorization page covers the candidate side, and our FCRA compliance guide for employers covers yours.
PreHireBadge asks candidates to verify identity with a government ID and a live selfie before the report is run, which ties the record to the right person. That matters because a record that belongs to someone else is the most avoidable error in this process.
4. Run the check and read the result
Order the report only after the conditional offer, and only for the scope the job justifies. Our national criminal report searches county, state and federal courts, sex offender registries and federal watchlists, and reports typically arrive the same day, so the offer does not sit open for long.
5. Do the individualized assessment
If nothing relevant appears, finish onboarding. If something does, apply the three factors and write down your reasoning. Keep that note with the report.
6. Send the preliminary notice
If you are considering withdrawing the offer, covered employers must typically send a written notice of the preliminary decision, include a copy of the report, and allow the applicant at least five business days to respond or dispute the findings. Some places set other windows, and the FCRA has its own pre-adverse action requirement, so use the longest one that applies.
7. Consider the response, then decide
After the response period, conduct a second assessment. If you reach a final adverse decision, send written notice of the final action along with information on the right to file a complaint, as the L.A. County rule describes. If the applicant sends timely proof of inaccuracy or rehabilitation, pause and reconsider, as San Francisco requires.
The notices and timing are where most employers slip. Our adverse action guide walks through the common mistakes, and the Pre-Adverse Action Notice Response Planner helps you plan the response window.
Exceptions, complaints and penalties
Exceptions exist in every regime. The federal Fair Chance Act identifies some positions to which the prohibition does not apply, and states and cities typically carve out roles where another law requires a background check, such as certain positions working with children or in financial services. Whether a role qualifies is a legal question for your employment attorney.
Complaints go to the enforcing agency. For federal hiring, the Act requires a complaint process for applicants, and the Federal Register summary describes adverse action and appeal procedures when an agency employee is alleged to have violated the rules. State and local laws name their own enforcers, usually a civil rights or labor department, and the notices above are supposed to tell applicants where to file.

Penalties vary by jurisdiction and can include fines and damages, so check the enforcing agency’s current page for each place you hire. The cheapest protection is the same in every case: follow the timing, keep the written assessment, and send the notices on time.
Where employers get tripped up
- Using the wrong jurisdiction. Rules usually follow where the work is performed, so a remote hire in a covered city can bring that city’s ordinance with them.
- Skipping the written assessment. A decision with no recorded reasoning is hard to defend.
- Cutting the response window short. Rejecting on day three when five business days are required is a violation by itself.
- Treating all records alike. Blanket exclusions conflict with the individualized-assessment principle in the EEOC guidance.
- Missing records of what was sent. Without timestamps and copies of notices, you cannot show you complied.
Negligent hiring claims push in the opposite direction, which is why a documented, role-relevant screening process protects you from both sides. See our negligent hiring statistics for how often screening gaps show up in litigation.
Our perspective
Employers tell us the legal steps are not the hard part. The hard part is doing them the same way every time, across cities and hiring managers, when a hire needs to start this week.
That is why we put the compliance work inside the product. Every report goes through identity verification with a government ID and a live selfie. Adverse action handling, compliance documents and audit-ready evidence bundles come with every account, and Platform Access costs $0 per month. You pay per report, with no subscription.
Fair chance law asks you to slow down at the right moment: ask later, assess carefully, give the person a chance to respond. A workflow that prompts each of those steps, and records that it happened, lets you hire people with records fairly and still prove it.
Matt
Run fair chance screening with PreHireBadge
If you hire employees or contractors and want the check, the notices and the evidence trail in one place, PreHireBadge is built for it. You order a national criminal report per candidate through the dashboard, bulk CSV upload, the API or chat. There is no subscription, and the adverse action workflow and compliance tracking are part of every account. Candidates can also carry a portable 90-day status badge.

See pricing and Platform Access, or read how fair chance compliance is built into every check. Gig platforms screening many contractors can start from the homepage.
FAQ
Which states have fair chance laws for private employers?
According to the National Employment Law Project’s 2021 guide, fifteen states cover private employers: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington. Many cities and counties add their own rules. Because lists change, confirm the current law for every place you hire.
What is a fair chance hiring policy?
It is a written policy that delays record questions and background checks until later in hiring, then requires an individualized review of any record against the job. It also sets out the notices and response time owed to an applicant if you decide against hiring them. A consistent policy keeps every manager on the same steps.
Can an employer ask about a criminal record on an application?
In many jurisdictions, no. California’s Fair Chance Act generally bars employers with five or more employees from asking before a job offer, and the federal rule bars most agency requests before a conditional offer. Where no law applies, a delayed question is still the safer practice.
How long must an applicant have to respond to a preliminary rejection?
Under the L.A. County ordinance, at least five business days after the written preliminary notice and a copy of the report. Other jurisdictions set different periods, so follow the longest one that applies to the candidate’s workplace.
Sources
- Ban the Box: U.S. Cities, Counties, and States Adopt Fair Chance Policies (NELP)
- Fair Chance Hiring (NELP)
- Fair Chance Hiring Guide
- Private Sector Fair Chance Hiring
- Fair Chance to Compete for Jobs (Federal Register)
- OPM Fair Chance regulations memorandum
- Los Angeles County Fair Chance Ordinance notice
- San Francisco Fair Chance Ordinance
- EEOC Enforcement Guidance (2012)
- Criminal Justice and Employment Discrimination (Harvard Law)
- Applicant Screening at Theme Parks





