Skip to main content
PreHireBadge
Guides

EEOC Background Check Guidance: What Employers Do Now

PreHireBadge TeamNovember 8, 202611 min read

The EEOC rescinded its criminal records guidance, but Title VII, the FCRA and state fair chance laws still apply. Here is what employers should do now.

standard employment reports

Invite a candidate, they verify their ID on their phone, and you get a national criminal report. Flat price, nothing monthly.

Get started See pricing

EEOC Background Check Guidance: What Employers Do Now

Criminal history screening policy pages on desk

The EEOC has voted to rescind its 2012 enforcement guidance on arrest and conviction records, effective immediately. That changes what the agency says, not what the law requires. Title VII, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and state and local fair chance laws still govern how you screen candidates, so a compliant process looks much like it did last year: a clear written policy, proper disclosure and authorization, individualized review, and correct adverse action steps.

Prehirebadge
Screen Candidates With Compliance in Mind
PreHireBadge provides FCRA-regulated background checks with identity verification, helping employers screen candidates without a subscription.
Explore background checks

TL;DR

  • The EEOC rescinded its 2012 criminal records enforcement guidance. Title VII itself did not change, and neither did the FCRA.
  • Disparate treatment is still unlawful, and private disparate impact claims remain available.
  • State and local ban-the-box and fair chance laws now carry much of the practical weight, so check where your candidates work.
  • The FCRA process is unchanged: stand-alone disclosure, written authorization, pre-adverse action notice, then final notice.
  • Keep your records. Three years is the common retention period for FCRA notices and authorizations.

Table of Contents

What the EEOC rescission actually changed

The EEOC’s announcement says the rescission does not restore older policy statements and does not require employers to abandon lawful practices they adopted in response to the 2012 guidance. Chair Andrea Lucas framed it as a reaffirmation that the agency enforces Title VII within constitutional and congressional limits. It is not a license for unlawful discrimination (EEOC).

Law firm analysis points the same way. Morgan Lewis describes the move as largely formalizing an existing approach of deprioritizing disparate impact investigations, while courts keep their authority to evaluate discrimination claims about criminal history screening. Phelps adds that disparate treatment remains unlawful, private disparate impact claims remain available, ban-the-box laws still apply and the FCRA is unchanged.

In plain terms: the federal agency is less likely to open an investigation on a disparate impact theory. A candidate, a plaintiff’s lawyer or a state agency can still bring a claim. Dropping your screening discipline because the guidance is gone would be a mistake.

What the EEOC rescission actually changed

Why the old guidance still matters as a playbook

The 2012 document is no longer the agency’s current position, but the legal concepts behind it come from Title VII and decades of case law. Those concepts are what a court or state regulator will reason with, so they are still the best template for a defensible policy.

Two kinds of discrimination

Title VII covers two theories in criminal history screening. Disparate treatment means treating applicants with the same record differently because of race, color, religion, sex or national origin. Disparate impact means a uniform exclusion that disproportionately screens out people of a particular race or national origin, which is lawful only if it is “job related and consistent with business necessity” (EEOC Q&A, 2012).

The same Q&A states that an arrest alone does not establish that someone engaged in criminal conduct, and that a policy excluding everyone with any record will not meet the business necessity standard unless federal law requires it.

The three factors

The EEOC has long recommended weighing the nature and gravity of the offense, the time that has passed since the conviction or sentence, and the nature of the job (EEOC informal discussion letter, 2010). These trace back to a 1977 Eighth Circuit case, Green v. Missouri Pacific Railroad, and the 2012 guidance explained that a targeted screen built on them should be narrowly tailored to conduct with a tight connection to the position (EEOC Enforcement Guidance, 2012).

Individualized assessment

The 2012 guidance described an individualized assessment as three parts: telling the person they have been screened out, giving them a chance to show the exclusion should not apply to their circumstances, and considering whether that extra information warrants an exception (EEOC Enforcement Guidance, 2012). That maps neatly onto the FCRA pre-adverse action step, which is why the two processes work well as one workflow.

Three steps in an individualized assessment

The EEOC guidance that still stands for employers

The EEOC’s plain-language guide, Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know, covers the basics every hiring team should know. Whenever you use background information in an employment decision, you must comply with the federal nondiscrimination laws covering race, color, national origin, sex, religion, disability, genetic information and age 40 or older. The guide advises you to:

  • apply the same standards to everyone, regardless of protected characteristics;
  • take special care when a decision rests on background problems more common among certain groups;
  • be prepared to make exceptions for problems caused by a disability.

The EEOC also publishes an arrest and conviction records brochure with best practices: eliminate blanket exclusions, develop a narrowly tailored written screening policy, identify the essential requirements of each job, determine which specific offenses show unfitness for it, include an individualized assessment, and train managers on Title VII. Since that is simply good process, it is a sensible checklist whether or not the 2012 document is still in force.

The FCRA process, step by step

Title VII does not regulate how you obtain criminal history, but the FCRA sets the procedures when you get it from a third-party consumer reporting agency, and some states add protections (EEOC Q&A). Our fuller walkthrough is in the FCRA compliance guide for employers. The core sequence:

  1. Disclose. Give the applicant a written, stand-alone notice that you may obtain a consumer report for employment purposes. A free FCRA disclosure and authorization generator can help you produce the forms.
  2. Get written authorization. The candidate must agree in writing before you order the report. The FCRA authorization page explains what candidates are consenting to.
  3. Certify to the reporting agency. You confirm you notified the applicant, obtained permission, complied with the FCRA and will not discriminate or misuse the information. For an investigative report you must also tell the applicant about their right to a description of the investigation’s nature and scope (EEOC).
  4. Review the report consistently. Apply your written criteria to every candidate for the same role.
  5. Send the pre-adverse action notice. Before deciding not to hire, provide a copy of the report and a written summary of rights, then allow reasonable time to respond. Five business days is generally considered sufficient (Employment Law Insights, 2026).
  6. Send the final notice if you proceed. It must give the reporting agency’s contact details, state that the agency did not make the decision and cannot explain the specific reasons, and describe the person’s right to dispute the report and get a free copy within 60 days (SHRM toolkit).

Timings and mistakes are covered in detail in our adverse action guide, and the pre-adverse action response planner helps you track the response window.

State and local laws now do much of the work

With federal agency guidance gone, the rules closest to your candidate matter most. The EEOC’s own guide tells employers to check state and municipal laws because some regulate the use of background reports (EEOC).

Fisher Phillips points to several examples that still apply after the rescission:

Jurisdiction What to know
California Fair Chance Act: no criminal history inquiry until after a conditional offer
Pennsylvania Criminal History Record Information Act (CHRIA)
Philadelphia Expanded ordinance, effective January 2026
Washington State Expanded Fair Chance Act, effective July 1, 2026, for employers with 15 or more employees
Seattle Fair Chance Employment Ordinance, in place since November 1, 2013

The list is far broader. Troutman Pepper Locke lists more than two dozen jurisdictions with some limits on using criminal history in hiring, including California, Colorado, Illinois, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Texas and Washington, plus the District of Columbia. Our ban the box guide explains how timing rules, such as waiting until after a conditional offer, change the order of your process. If you hire across several states, a screening flow built around the strictest rule you face is easier to run than a different flow per location.

Build a written screening policy that holds up

Both the EEOC’s best practices and the law firm commentary converge on the same internal controls. Fisher Phillips recommends reviewing HR forms and practices, documenting individualized assessments, auditing disclosures and adverse action notices, training HR teams and hiring managers, and consulting counsel. A practical version:

  • Define the role requirements first. What does the job actually involve: cash handling, driving, access to homes, work with vulnerable people? The screening requirements by role tool is a starting point.
  • Name the offenses that matter and why. Tie each to the duties of the job, with a look-back period you can explain.
  • Replace blanket bans. “No records, ever” is the policy most likely to be challenged, unless federal law requires the exclusion.
  • Write down the individualized review. Record who reviewed, what the candidate said and how you weighed the three factors.
  • Train the people who decide. Managers who see report results need to know what they may and may not consider.
  • Check with counsel before changing policy. Phelps recommends legal review before revising background check procedures, and that is especially wise when you operate in several states.

A worked example

Suppose you hire delivery drivers and a candidate’s report shows a conviction for a nonviolent property offense from many years ago. A blanket rule would reject them. A targeted approach asks whether the offense bears on the duties of a driver, how long ago it happened and how serious it was. If you conclude it does bear on the job, you send the pre-adverse action notice, listen to the response, and document your decision either way. The point is not to hire everyone. It is to be able to show the decision followed a consistent, job-related rule.

Keep the records that prove your process

When a decision is challenged, your paperwork is your defense. Under FCRA Section 615, a common retention guideline is at least three years for adverse action notices, pre-adverse action notices, final letters and supporting documents. The same period is commonly applied to consumer report copies given to applicants, written authorizations and certification forms (BackGroundChecker, 2026). Retain records as required by the state and federal law that applies to you, and when you dispose of them, shred or burn paper and destroy electronic data so it cannot be read or reconstructed (SHRM toolkit). Ask counsel whether your state requires longer retention.

Keeping compliance consistent across teams and platforms

The hard part is rarely knowing the rules. It is applying them the same way across recruiters, locations and, for gig platforms, thousands of contractors. Inconsistent notices, forms that differ by manager and missing evidence are what create exposure.

Three habits help:

  • Use one disclosure and authorization template, reviewed periodically.
  • Order every check through one system so the same steps happen every time.
  • Keep the evidence for each candidate in one place, not in inboxes.

Our fair chance compliance features are built around exactly this idea, and the free PreHireBadge Academy offers FCRA training and certificates for your hiring team. For broader context, see the full guide to running a background check on an employee and our background check statistics.

Run compliant checks without a subscription

PreHireBadge is an automated, FCRA-compliant background check service for employers, small businesses and gig platforms. Every candidate verifies identity with a government ID and a live selfie, and the report searches county, state and federal courts, sex offender registries and federal watchlists, typically delivering results the same day. You pay per report, with no subscription and no hidden fees. Platform Access is $0 per month, and you can order by chat, bulk CSV upload or API.

The compliance steps that trip teams up are built in: adverse action handling, compliance documents and audit-ready evidence bundles come with every account.

Prehirebadge

See how it works on the pricing page, or read about the national criminal check and the sources behind each report. Candidates can also carry a portable 90-day background badge from employer to employer.

Our perspective

When guidance disappears, the temptation is to loosen the process. We think the opposite is smarter. The laws that protect candidates and employers are the same as last month, and the people most likely to test them are plaintiffs and state regulators, not federal press releases.

The way we see it, compliance should not depend on whether every recruiter remembers every step. It should be automatic: identity verified up front, the disclosure and authorization captured, adverse action notices generated in the right order, and an evidence bundle you can hand to an auditor. That is why we built those steps into the product rather than leaving them to a checklist.

We also believe screening should be affordable enough that small employers and gig platforms run it for every hire instead of skipping it. Flat per-report pricing, with no subscription, makes a consistent policy practical.

Matt

FAQ

Is the EEOC’s criminal background check guidance still in effect?

No. The EEOC voted to rescind its 2012 enforcement guidance on arrest and conviction records. Title VII and the FCRA are unchanged, though, and courts and state agencies can still evaluate screening practices.

Can I still reject a candidate for a criminal record?

Yes, when the decision is lawful, consistent and job related. Avoid blanket exclusions unless a law requires one, weigh the offense, the time passed and the job, and follow the FCRA pre-adverse action and final notice steps. State or local fair chance laws may limit when you can ask or what you can consider.

Do ban-the-box laws still apply after the rescission?

Yes. They are state and local laws, so the EEOC’s action does not touch them. California, Washington State, Philadelphia and Seattle are among the places with such rules, and many more jurisdictions have limits on criminal history in hiring.

What does the FCRA require before I run a check?

You must give a written, stand-alone disclosure, get the applicant’s written authorization and certify your compliance to the reporting agency. If the result leads to an adverse decision, you then send a pre-adverse action notice with the report and a summary of rights, followed by a final notice.

How long should I keep background check records?

Three years is the commonly cited period for FCRA adverse action notices, authorizations and related documents. Your state may require longer, so confirm with counsel.

Sources

Keep reading

Turn the research into a screening step.

Send a candidate an invite, they consent and verify their ID on their phone, and ScreenForge Labs furnishes a national criminal employment report for $10 flat. No subscription, and no SSN for you to handle.

Method
Drafted by PreHireBadge Research with AI-assisted search of public data. Figures that could not be matched to a published source were cut, and each remaining one links to where it came from. Found a mistake? Email support@prehirebadge.com and the report will be fixed.
Not legal advice
General information only. Neither PreHireBadge nor ScreenForge Labs is a law firm, and FCRA and state screening rules turn on the facts of each case. Ask an employment attorney about your own hiring process.