Identity Verification and Background Checks: How They Fit Together
Identity verification confirms who the candidate is; a background check shows their record. Learn how to combine them, stay FCRA-compliant, and screen remote hires.
standard employment reports
Invite a candidate, they verify their ID on their phone, and you get a national criminal report. Flat price, nothing monthly.
Get started See pricingIn this report
Identity Verification and Background Checks: How They Fit Together

Identity verification confirms that the person applying is the person they claim to be. A background check then reports what the records say about that person. Run them as one workflow, ID first and records second, and you avoid the most common screening failure: a clean report that belongs to someone else. This guide explains how the two steps differ, when each belongs in your hiring process, which federal rules apply, and how to set it up for remote candidates and gig workers.
TL;DR
- Identity verification proves the candidate is real and matches their documents. A background check reports on records tied to that identity. You need both for a result you can rely on.
- E-Verify and Form I-9 are employment-eligibility steps. They happen after an accepted offer and are not a substitute for identity proofing or a criminal search.
- Under the FCRA, you need a stand-alone disclosure and written authorization before ordering a report, and a defined process if you act on what it shows.
- For remote hires and gig platforms, a government ID plus a live selfie is the practical way to tie a person to a report before any search runs.
- Our flat $5 per report includes ID and selfie verification with no subscription.
Table of Contents
- Identity verification vs. a background check
- What identity verification can and cannot confirm
- When to verify identity in the hiring process
- FCRA rules when you order a report
- Remote candidates and gig workers
- What a verified background check searches
- What it costs to verify identity
- Run verified checks for $5 a report
- Setting up your process: a checklist
- FAQ
- Sources
Identity verification vs. a background check
The two terms get mixed up because they often arrive in one order form. They answer different questions.
Identity verification asks: is this person who they say they are? It examines a government-issued ID, checks that it looks genuine, and confirms the person presenting it matches the photo. Online, that usually means a photo of the document and a live selfie compared against it.
A background check asks: what do records show about this person? The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says employment reports often include credit checks, criminal background checks, public records such as bankruptcy filings and court documents, and employment-history information. Which of those you order depends on the role.
The order matters. A criminal search runs on a name and date of birth. If the person at the other end of the application used someone else’s details, the search returns a perfectly accurate report about a stranger. Verifying identity first closes that gap.
| Identity verification | Background check | E-Verify / Form I-9 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Question answered | Is this the real person? | What do records show? | Is this person authorized to work in the U.S.? |
| Typical inputs | Government ID, live selfie | Name, date of birth, identifiers | Form I-9 data |
| When | Before the search runs | After written authorization | After an accepted offer |
| Governed mainly by | Your own screening policy | FCRA, EEOC guidance, state and local law | Immigration law, USCIS rules |
What identity verification can and cannot confirm
A document-and-selfie check can establish three things: the ID appears genuine, the photo on it resembles the person in front of the camera, and the person is physically present at the moment of capture rather than showing a photo of a photo. That last point is what a “liveness” step is for.
What it does not do is tell you about a person’s history. It does not tell you whether someone has a record, whether past employers would rehire them, or whether they hold a license. It also does not replace judgment: if the selfie does not match, or the ID is unreadable, a person should look at the case and, usually, ask the candidate to try again with better lighting or a different document.
How fast it works depends on the provider. In our case, candidates complete the ID and selfie step as part of ordering, and reports typically come back the same day. You can read how the step works on our identity verification feature page.

Why E-Verify is not an identity check
Many employers assume E-Verify covers identity. It does not in the way remote screening needs. E-Verify.gov states plainly that the system does not verify identity biometrically: it confirms the validity of biographic information, and employers must still examine identity documents to make sure they appear genuine and relate to the person presenting them.
That is one reason identity proofing, employment eligibility and criminal screening are three separate controls. If you want the full comparison, our guide to E-Verify vs. Form I-9 walks through it.
When to verify identity in the hiring process
There are two moments, and they carry different rules.
Before the offer: confirm the applicant for screening
When you plan to run a consumer report, verifying the applicant’s identity at the point of authorization makes sense. It ties the signed consent to a real person and the search to the right identifiers. This is your own process choice, not a federal requirement, so write it into your screening policy and apply it to every candidate for the same role.
After the offer: Form I-9 and E-Verify
Employment-eligibility checks have a hard timing rule. The EEOC says federal law prohibits employers from conducting the Form I-9 and E-Verify processes before the employee has accepted an offer of employment. E-Verify’s own guidance agrees: employers may use it only after an accepted offer and a completed Form I-9, and it is not a prescreening tool.
The same EEOC page notes that the Immigration and Nationality Act requires employers to verify the identity and employment eligibility of employees hired after November 6, 1986, by completing Form I-9 and reviewing documents. According to the USCIS employer handbook, you must complete Section 2 within three business days of employment beginning, by examining original, unexpired documents (or an acceptable receipt) to determine whether they appear genuine and relate to the person presenting them.
If you participate in E-Verify, USCIS says you must use it consistently for all new hires and may not terminate or take other adverse action solely because of a mismatch.
So the sequence for a typical W-2 hire looks like this:
- Candidate applies and receives your FCRA disclosure and authorization.
- Candidate verifies identity (ID and selfie) and the background report runs.
- You review results using a consistent standard and make an offer.
- After acceptance, the new hire completes Form I-9, and you run E-Verify if you participate.
FCRA rules when you order a report
Identity verification by itself is not a consumer report. Once you order a background report from a screening company, the Fair Credit Reporting Act applies. The EEOC explains that you must give the applicant a stand-alone written disclosure, obtain written authorization, and certify to the reporting company that your use is permissible and nondiscriminatory. The CFPB’s consumer guidance likewise says an employer generally must get written permission first, with a trucking-industry exception concerning the form of permission.
The disclosure has to be its own document, not buried in an application. If you need a starting point, our free FCRA disclosure and authorization generator produces one, and the FCRA compliance guide for employers covers the full lifecycle.
Apply standards consistently
The EEOC also says screening standards must be applied consistently, and that federal protections cover race, color, national origin, sex, religion, disability, genetic information and age 40 or older. State and local rules can add requirements, such as fair-chance hiring laws, so check the rules where your workers are based.
Identity checks should follow the same logic. If you ask one candidate to submit a selfie, ask all candidates for that role. Do not request extra documents based on how someone looks or sounds, and do not ask for specific documents to establish work authorization before an offer.
When the result is unfavorable
If you may decide against a candidate based on the report, the FCRA requires a pre-adverse and a final adverse action step. The law does not fix an exact waiting period between them. Law firm Littler reports that five business days has been a commonly accepted standard, though recent litigation suggests allowing more time where appropriate.
After adverse action, the EEOC says you must name the reporting company, state that it did not make the hiring decision, and tell the applicant about the right to dispute the report’s accuracy or completeness and to get another free report within 60 days. Our adverse action guide explains notices and timing, and the free letter generator drafts both letters.
Remote candidates and gig workers
Remote hiring removes the step that used to do the identity work: a person looking at an ID across a desk. Gig platforms face the sharper version of this problem, since contractors onboard by the thousands and never meet anyone.
A workable remote process has four parts:
- Capture a government ID and a live selfie before any record search is run.
- Compare the selfie to the ID photo and confirm the capture is live.
- Run the records search only on the verified identity, so the report reflects the person who actually applied.
- Keep the evidence. Store the consent, the verification result and the report together so you can show what you did and why.
Platforms that onboard at volume usually need this automated. Our API and webhooks let you order and receive results inside your own flow, and bulk CSV upload and chat ordering cover smaller teams.
What still needs a human
Automation handles the clear cases. A person should review the rest: a name that differs between the ID and the application (marriage, legal name changes, suffixes), a blurry or damaged document, a selfie that fails repeatedly, or a result that does not line up with what the candidate told you. Treat these as prompts to ask a question, not as proof of fraud. Give the candidate a way to resubmit and a way to explain, and apply the same handling to everyone.
What a verified background check searches
Once identity is confirmed, the search itself needs to be broad enough to matter. Our National Criminal Report covers county, state and federal courts, sex offender registries and federal watchlists. A search of only one layer, such as a single state database, can miss records filed in other jurisdictions. You can see what sits behind the report on our data sources page and the details of the search on the national criminal check page.
If the role also depends on a candidate’s work history, pair the criminal search with employment history verification. For roles where practical knowledge matters, such as retail, food service, home care or cleaning, we also offer job-knowledge tests.
What it costs to verify identity
Costs depend on which control you mean, and it is worth keeping them apart.
- E-Verify is free to the employer. HRpresso reports that running the federal check costs an employer $0, but that fees can come from employer agents and from HR or payroll software that sells it as an add-on, such as $4.00 per case submission at one provider and $12.00 per new hire per year plus a $250 setup fee at another (reported October 18, 2026).
- Identity verification inside a background check varies by provider, and some charge it as an extra line item.
- PreHireBadge includes photo ID and liveness verification at no extra cost within a flat $5 per report. There is no subscription, and platform access is $0 per month. See current terms on our pricing page.
Flat pricing makes budgeting simple: your screening cost is the number of candidates times one price, with no add-ons for the verification step.
Our perspective
Most hiring teams we talk to treat identity as an afterthought: a name goes into a search box and a report comes back. We think that order is backwards. A background report is only as trustworthy as the identity behind it, so we built the ID and live selfie step into every order rather than selling it separately.
That matters most for the employers and platforms who cannot meet candidates in person. A small business hiring its first remote employee and a gig platform onboarding thousands of drivers have the same need: be sure the person is real, then search the right records. Doing both at one flat price means a small team can follow the same careful process a large HR department would.
We also automate the compliance work around the report, including adverse action handling and audit-ready evidence, because the paperwork is where good intentions usually slip. Verify first, search second, document everything.
Matt
Run verified checks for $5 a report
If you are ready to put identity first in your screening, PreHireBadge combines ID and selfie verification, a national criminal search, built-in compliance steps and audit-ready evidence in one report with no subscription. Candidates who pass also receive a portable 90-day status badge they can share, which can save repeat checks when they move between platforms. Start from our pricing page or explore the free hiring and FCRA tools.

To see how the portable status works for candidates, visit the portable badge page.
Setting up your process: a checklist
- Write the policy. Define which roles get which checks and what results lead to review. Apply it to everyone in the same role.
- Send the disclosure and authorization. Use a stand-alone document, and keep the signed copy. The FCRA authorization page explains what candidates see.
- Verify identity before searching. ID plus live selfie, with a human review path for exceptions.
- Run the report and review individually. Look at the record in the context of the job rather than rejecting on a blanket rule, and check state and local fair-chance rules.
- Handle adverse action properly. Use the two-step notices and give the candidate time to respond. Our adverse action workflow automates this.
- After an accepted offer, complete Form I-9 and run E-Verify if you participate.
- Keep records. Consent, verification result, report, notices and decision.
Candidate rights to keep in mind
Candidates are not passive in this process. The CFPB’s Circular 2024-06 says reporting companies must use reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy, disclose file information to workers on request, and investigate disputes. In a CFPB report on background screening, the agency says a reporting company generally has 30 days to investigate a dispute, with 15 more days in some circumstances. The same document says that if an employer obtains a report without required permission, the applicant may complain to the CFPB or the Federal Trade Commission.
Building your process around these rights is good practice: it protects candidates and keeps your decisions defensible.
FAQ
Is identity verification part of a background check?
Not necessarily. Identity verification is a separate step that confirms the person is who they claim to be, and many screening orders skip it. Records searches then run on the name and date of birth supplied. We include ID and selfie verification in every report so the search is tied to a confirmed person.
Can I use E-Verify to verify a job applicant’s identity?
No, not before an offer. E-Verify can be used only after the offer is accepted and Form I-9 is completed, and it matches biographic data rather than verifying identity biometrically. For pre-offer screening, use your own identity verification step alongside an FCRA-compliant report.
Do I need the candidate’s permission to run a background check?
Yes. Under the FCRA, you must give a stand-alone written disclosure and get the candidate’s written authorization before obtaining a consumer report from a screening company. A trucking-industry exception concerns the form of permission. State and local laws may add requirements.
How do I verify the identity of a remote candidate?
Ask for a government-issued photo ID and a live selfie, compare them, and confirm the capture is live. Route unclear cases to a person for review and let the candidate retry. Apply the same steps to every candidate for the role, and keep the evidence with the report.
Can a candidate carry a background check to another employer?
In some cases, yes. We issue a portable 90-day status badge to candidates who complete a check through us, which they can share with employers or platforms. Employers should still follow their own FCRA obligations when relying on a report for their own decisions.
Sources
- CFPB: what employers see in an employment background check
- E-Verify: Fact vs. Fiction
- EEOC: Pre-Employment Inquiries and Citizenship
- USCIS Handbook for Employers: Completing Section 2
- USCIS Handbook for Employers: E-Verify
- EEOC: Background Checks, What Employers Need to Know
- Littler: Federal Courts Increase Scrutiny of Employer Compliance with FCRA’s Adverse Action
- HRpresso: Is E-Verify Free?
- CFPB Circular 2024-06
- CFPB: Closer look at background screening





